AN INSURGENCY CAN BE OF MAINLY TWO TYPES: NON-VIOLENT AND VIOLENT
In both the insurgency persons involved has to be ready for punishment.
In both the cases, one has to make up its mind to leave its relatives, friends, home, job, town and even the country. This inevitably happens in more or less proportion. One’s family is off course going to suffer socially, mentally and monetarily.
Then what is the difference between these two?
INSURGENCY WITH VIOLENCE:
A person goes with weapon,
A person can be non-transparent,
A person goes underground,
A person fights physically,
A person gets beaten,
A person goes to jail,
A person faces litigation and say if a person gets convicted then the person would undergo punishments like house arrest, jail, life time jail, exile jail, up to capital punishment.
A WAR ON MORAL GROUND AND WITH FAIR PRINCIPLES
In old days in India a war was played associated with fair principles. Rama, Pandava, Chandra Gupta, Rana Pratap, Shivaji and many others, say lastly Subhash Chandra Bose had waged war on moral grounds. We leave this aside in this blog. One can watch Subrhamanian Swami on this topic on You Tube.
INSURGENCY WITH NON-VIOLENCE:
A person is always ready for discussion,
A person keeps transparency,
A person goes without weapon,
A person does everything openly,
A person gives a notice,
A person suffers all tortures physically and mentally,
A person gets beaten,
A person goes to jail,
A person faces litigation and say the person gets convicted then the person would undergo punishment like house arrest, jail, life time jail, exile jail and capital punishment.
CAN WE RULED OUT CAPITAL PUNISHMENT TO AN INSURGENT COMMITTED TO NON-VIOLENCE?
A person may not get capital punishment. But this punishment cannot be ruled out if the government is non-democratic.
Democracy is a relative term. A government could be less democratic and could be hypocrite. Such government can kill a person in many other ways.
We know as to how the life of Shyama Prasad Mukharjee was ended up.
We know very well as to how Jai Prakasha Narain was treated medically in the jail and how was he taken to near death condition by the Nehruvian progeny Indira Ghandi.
We know about a lot of persons as to how they had been disappeared from the world by the Nehruvian Governments.
This indicates that the non-violent person or a group of persons has to be ready for facing indirectly imposed capital punishment.
POLICY IN FREEDOM STRUGGLE
What was the decided policy between violent Insurgents and non-violent insurgent during Indian freedom struggle?
Both of them had decided that they should not come into mutual conflict. They should run the struggle on their own principles.
The supporters of Bhagat Singh defame MK Gandhi on the plea that MK Gandhi did not save the life of Bhagat Singh. According to them, it was possible for MK Gandhi to save the life of Bhagat Singh. As said by them a proposal was made by the British.
First of all one should understand that an insurgent has to be ready for any punishment including the capital punishment. The insurgent is supposed to foresee it and the insurgent is supposed to accept it, in case the capital punishment comes to the insurgent.
Bhagat Singh was not timid. He was not scared of punishment. He had foreseen it. He was ready to accept it. He had not prayed for any relief in punishment.
Now suppose, MK Gandhi might had prayed the British to provide relief to Bhagat Singh who believed in insurgency with violation, what could British had done?
As for Gandhi, the British were cunning and not reliable. Besides this it was beyond doubt that British could use such approach of MK Gandhi to defame him maximum. One should not be silly to ask Mahatma Gandhi to fall in the trap of British.
WHY THE PSEUDO SECULAR LEADERS ASK MODI TO SUBMIT APOLOGY ON 2002 RIOTS?
Is it that, in case Narendra Modi had submitted apology the matter would have been ended up there?
No. It would have given a big weapon to pseudo secular to demoralize Narendra Modi and BJP too.
Modi is equally clever and smart like MK Gandhi.
You must be smart enough to understand Narendra Modi and Mahatma Gandhi.
A time has come to apply logic and spell out logically because your stupidity can harm the BJP lead Government.
Shirish Mohanlal Dave
Tags: Insurgence, Agitation, Violence, Non-violence, punishment, MK Gandhi, Godse, notice, communication